House Favorites
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$11.99
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
$19.99
Oil & Garlic White Pizza
$11.99
Oil & Garlic Sicilian White Pizza
$19.99
Gourmet Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Boneless tails smothered in our famous wing sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese & a side of blue cheese dressing. *Try with BBQ*
$13.99
Fuggeddaboudit Pizza
Pronounced (fa-get-a-bout-it)…our traditional pie topped with pepperoni, sausage(hot & sweet blend), onions, mushrooms, red bell peppers, black olives & extra cheese.
$13.99
Philadelphia Cheesesteak Pizza
thinly chopped ribeye beef steak with provolone cheese & shredded cooper sharp cheese & fried onions.
$14.49
"Da Veggie" Pizza
Oil & garlic pie with breaded eggplant, blistered tomatoes, broccoli florets & spinach topped with mozzarella cheese & whipped ricotta cheese.
$12.99
Pizza Palermo
Fresh plum tomato marinara sauce, mozzarella & provolone cheese, grilled chicken, spinach & roasted red peppers.
$20.49
Chicken Bacon Poblano Ranch Pizza
White pie with crispy chicken cutlet, bacon, and poblano ranch dressing.
$21.49
Stockton Bomb Pizza
Buffalo tails, mozzarella sticks, French fries in mild sauce. Served with a side of Blue Cheese.
$16.99
Margherita Pizza
Fresh plum tomato marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese topped with basil.
$18.99
Chicken Vodka Parmesan Pizza
Vodka sauce pie with breaded chicken cutlet & melted mozzarella cheese
$21.49
Crispy Pepperoni Hot Honey Pie
Our delicious pepperoni with a touch of Mike's hot honey oil.
$20.99
Upside-Down Pizza
A layer of Mozzarella Cheese beneath marinara sauce topped with parmesan cheese.
$16.99
Nashville Chicken Pickle Pizza
A white garlic sauce base with our Nashville hot chicken tails, mozzarella cheese & diced pickles topped with buttermilk ranch.
$21.49
Meatball Ricotta Pizza
Topped with red sauce, homemade meatballs, mozzarella cheese & whipped ricotta
$20.99
Hot Honey Italian Pizza
16" red pizza topped with diced ham, genoa salami, long hots, mozzarella cheese, & hot honey drizzle.
$21.49
Appetizers & Sides
Burrata Bruschetta App
Blistered tomato bruschetta finished with creamy burrata & sweet roasted red peppers. Served with garlic crostini.
$14.99
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Served with tortilla chips.
$11.99
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.
$9.49
Meat & Cheese Board
Assorted Italian meats, fresh mozzarella, Sharp provolone cheese, roasted red peppers & olives
$19.99
Garlic Bread App
Toasted AC sub roll brushed with garlic & butter blend
$5.99
Meatball & Ricotta App
4 meatballs in our homemade red sauce topped with whipped ricotta
$13.99
Italian Mac n Cheese Bites
4 Mac n Cheese bites. Served with a side of Vodka Sauce
$10.49
Hot Veggie App Sampler
2 Italian mac n cheese bites, 3 mozzarella sticks, onion rings & 4 fried zucchini sticks. Served with a side of vodka sauce.
$18.99
Cold Veggie App Sampler
Blistered tomatoes, roasted red peppers, charred zucchini, charred eggplant. Served with a side of hummus & marinara sauce.
$17.99
Fried Zucchini Stick
8 Golden fried zucchini sticks served with a side of poblano ranch.
$9.99
Soups
Pasta Fagioli Soup
$6.49
Chicken Pastina Soup
"Italian Penicillin"
$7.49
French Onion Soup
$8.99
Salads
Garden Salad
A bed of mixed greens topped with blistered tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, & roasted red peppers.
$10.49
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with croutons, & parmesan cheese
$10.49
Spring Mix Salad
Spring mix lettuce, sliced tomatoes, red onions, feta cheese, walnuts, & dried cranberries. *Try with our raspberry vinaigrette dressing!
$11.49
Seaview Salad
Spring mix lettuce topped with almonds, strawberries, and feta cheese.
$12.99
Burrata & Prosciutto Salad
Spring mix lettuce topped with fresh burrata, prosciutto, roasted red peppers and balsamic glaze.
$13.99
Chopped Italian Antipasto Salad
Mixed greens, Chopped genoa salami, capicola, pepperoni, provolone cheese, Italian olives, & fire-roasted red peppers.
$13.99
Tuna Bruschetta Salad
A bed of mixed greens topped with a scoop of tuna salad, a scoop of fresh blistered tomato bruschetta, & fresh mozzarella cheese.
$15.49
Smithville Salad
Mixed greens topped with chilled shrimp, crab meat, avocado, cherry tomatoes, & old bay seasoning
$15.99
Cobb Salad
Mixed greens topped with grilled chicken, bacon, hard-boiled egg, cucumbers, and cherry tomatoes.
$15.99
Blackened Chicken Bruschetta Salad
A bed of mixed greens topped with grilled blackened chicken, a scoop of fresh blistered tomato bruschetta, & slices of fresh mozzarella cheese.
$15.99
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Three mild buffalo tails served over mixed greens topped with cucumbers, shredded mozzarella cheese & blistered tomatoes.
$15.99
Fries
French Fries
Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!
$5.29
Curly Fries
Our delicious curly fries.
$6.29
Sweet Potato Fries
Sweet potato fries! Wedges of sweet potatoes, tossed with oil, sprinkled with spices, and baked on high heat until browned and crispy at the edges.
$7.99
Onion Rings
$8.49
Calzone & Strombolis
Build Your Own
Fresh dough stuffed with mozzarella cheese, baked until golden brown. Served with a side of homemade marinara sauce. *Add Whipped Ricotta $0.99*
$12.99
Steak Stromboli
Fresh dough stuffed with mozzarella cheese & *NEW* ribeye beef steak, baked until golden brown. Served with a side of homemade marinara. *Add whipped ricotta $0.99*
$13.99
Veggie Stromboli
Breaded eggplant, blistered tomatoes, broccoli florets, spinach & mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of homemade marinara *Add whipped ricotta $0.99*
$13.99
Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
Tail tenders tossed in our famous mild sauce with mozzarella cheese in fresh dough baked golden brown. Served with a side of Blue Cheese
$13.99
The Works Stromboli
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, red bell peppers & mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of homemade marinara red sauce. *Add whipped ricotta $0.99*
$13.99
Chicken Bacon Poblano Stromboli
Chicken cutlet, bacon and mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of poblano ranch. *Add Whipped Ricotta $0.99*
$13.99
Chicken Vodka Parmesan Stromboli
Chicken cutlet & mozzarella cheese. Served with side of Vodka sauce. *Add Whipped Ricotta $0.99*
$13.99
Stockton Bomboli
Our buffalo tails, mozzarella sticks & French fries tossed in mild sauce with mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of Blue Cheese.
$14.99
Legendary Buffalo Style Chicken
Buffalo Tails
Boneless chicken breast lightly floured, fried crispy, & tossed in your choice of sauce. 6 & 12 Pieces comes with 1 bleu cheese, 24 pieces with 2 bleu cheese, 48 pieces with 4 bleu cheese, 100 pieces with 2 pints of bleu cheese.
$10.49
Buffalo Ears
Breaded chicken fingers fried crispy & tossed in your choice of sauce. 6 & 12 Pieces comes with 1 bleu cheese, 24 pieces with 2 bleu cheese, 48 pieces with 4 bleu cheese, 100 pieces with 2 pints of bleu cheese.
$10.49
Buffalo Wings
Chicken wings fried crispy & tossed in your choice of sauce. 6 & 12 Pieces comes with 1 bleu cheese, 24 pieces with 2 bleu cheese, 48 pieces with 4 bleu cheese, 100 pieces with 2 pints of bleu cheese.
$10.49
Specialty Hot Subs
Chicken Cutlet Caesar on Garlic Bread
Crispy chicken cutlet with romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing on fresh toasted garlic roll
$13.99
Spicy Chicken Parm on Garlic Bread
Breaded chicken cutlet, red diablo sauce, pepperoni chips & melted mozzarella cheese. Served on a Toasted Garlic Roll.
$16.99
Nonna's Shredded Beef Sub
Slow roasted Italian marinated beef with au jus & melted provolone cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Italian Roast Pork with Long Hots Sub
Slow roasted pork, broccoli rabe, long hots and sharp provolone cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Buffalo Ranchero Cutlet Sub
Crispy chicken cutlet tossed in mild sauce, topped with lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Chicken Cutlet, Burrata & Prosciutto Sub
topped balsamic glaze. Served on a Seeded Roll
$15.99
Chicken Sandwiches
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Crispy buttermilk fried chicken tossed in Nashville hot oil & pickles. Served on a brioche bun. (Try it grilled)
$13.99
Crispy Chicken Bacon Chipotle Ranch Sandwich
Crispy buttermilk fried chicken, bacon & chipotle ranch. Served on a brioche bun. (Try it grilled)
$13.99
Crispy Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Crispy buttermilk fried chicken, tossed in mild sauce with pepper jack cheese. Served on a brioche bun (try it grilled)
$13.99
Grilled Chicken Bruschetta Sandwich
Grilled chicken, homemade blistered tomato bruschetta & melted provolone cheese. Served on a brioche bun
$12.49
Chicken Avocado Sandwich
Grilled chicken, avocado, lettuce, bacon & rosemary mayo. Served on a brioche bun
$12.99
Blackened Alabama BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Blackened Chicken topped with Alabama BBQ sauce & sliced cheddar cheese. Served on a brioche bun.
$12.99
Costello’s Classics
Stockton Bomb Sub
Boneless buffalo tails, French fries, mozzarella sticks & bleu cheese dressing. Served on a Seeded Roll
$12.99
The Big Biff Sub
Shredded ribeye steak, bacon, seasoned curly fries, pepperoni chips & melted mozzarella cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
Grilled chicken steak mixed with our famous mild buffalo sauce, melted cooper sharp cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
The Godfather Sub
Chicken cutlet, breaded and golden brown, with spinach & roasted red peppers, & melted sharp provolone cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$11.99
Grilled Chicken & Roasted Pepper Sub
Grilled chicken breast, spinach, roasted red peppers & melted provolone cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$12.49
The Hail Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing served in a flour tortilla wrap.
$12.49
Cold Subs/Wraps
Regular Italian
Capicola, genoa salami, ham, & provolone cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$12.99
Turkey & Cheese
Your choice of cheese & toppings. Served on a Seeded Roll
$11.99
Ham & Cheese Sub
Your choice of cheese and toppings. Served on a Seeded Roll
$11.99
Hot Subs/Wraps
Cheesesteak
Shredded rib-eye steak topped with cooper sharp cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Chicken Cheesesteak
Shredded chicken steak topped with Cooper Sharp cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$13.99
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub
Breaded chicken cutlet, ham, mushrooms, homemade honey mustard & melted Swiss cheese.
$13.99
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Breaded chicken cutlet, homemade marinara sauce topped with a blend of melted sharp provolone & mozzarella cheese. Served on a Seeded roll. *Try with Vodka Sauce $0.99*
$15.99
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
Breaded eggplant, homemade marinara sauce topped with a blend of melted sharp provolone & mozzarella. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
Our homemade meatballs & marinara sauce topped with blend of melted sharp provolone & mozzarella cheese. Served on Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Sausage Parmigiana Sub
Hot & sweet Italian sausage, homemade marinara sauce topped with a blend of melted sharp provolone & mozzarella cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$15.99
Sausage, Peppers & Onions Sub
Hot & sweet Italian sausage slow roasted in our homemade red sauce topped with provolone cheese. Served on a Seeded Roll.
$16.99
Pasta
Basic Pasta
Our homemade marinara, alfredo, vodka, or rosa sauce served over your choice of pasta.
$14.99
Pasta with Italian Beef
Our homemade marinara sauce & Italian Beef with whipped ricotta cheese. Served over your choice of pasta.
$22.99
Shrimp Fra Diablo
Sauteed shrimp tossed in our homemade spicy fra diablo sauce with garlic and crushed red peppers. Served over your choice of pasta.
$22.99
Vodka Gnocchi
Pan seared Gnocchi tossed in our homemade vodka sauce with prosciutto & peas
$21.99
Pasta Meatball
3 homemade meatballs in our homemade marinara sauce served over your choice of pasta.
$20.99
Grown-Up Mac & Cheese
Mac n cheese mixed with our mild sauce and boneless tail tenders served over fusilli pasta
$22.99
Pollo
Chicken Francese
Battered chicken in white wine & lemon slices served over your choice of pasta.
$22.99
Chicken Marsala
Sauteed chicken in our homemade Marsala sauce & mushrooms served over your choice of pasta.
$22.99
Chicken Rosa
Sauteed chicken in our homemade Rosa sauce with spinach & red peppers served over your choice of pasta.
$22.99
Chicken Scarpariello
Sauteed chicken, sweet sausage, in white wine with, capers, hot cherry peppers, & lemon slices served over your choice of pasta.
$23.99
Kid's Menu
Kid's Mac & Cheese
Kid’s portion of penne pasta with our homemade cheese sauce.
$8.49
Kid's Pasta with Meatball
Penne pasta served with your choice of red or butter sauce & 1 (piece) meatball.
$8.49
Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries
Served with your choice of honey mustard or BBQ dipping sauce.
$10.99
Kid's Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Your choice of toast (white, wheat, or rye) with melted cooper sharp cheese & side of french fries.
$8.49
Desserts
Cannoli
$5.99
Classic Cheesecake
$6.99
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
$6.99
Chocolate Mud Pie
$6.99
Beverages
Soda
$2.99
Parmesan Pasta
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken cutlet with our homemade marinara sauce topped with a blend of melted sharp provolone & mozzarella cheese, over your choice of pasta. Served with a side of garlic bread.
$23.99
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta
Breaded eggplant with our homemade marinara sauce topped with a blend of sharp provolone & mozzarella cheese, over your choice of pasta. Served with a side of garlic bread.
$22.99
Sausage Parmesan
Hot & sweet Italian sausage with our homemade marinara sauce topped with a blend of melted sharp provolone and mozzarella cheese, over your choice of pasta. Served with a side of Garlic Bread.
$23.99
Vodka Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken cutlet with our creamy vodka sauce topped with a blend of melted sharp provolone & mozzarella cheese. Served over your choice of pasta. Served with a side of Garlic Bread.
$24.99
Nachos
Stockton Bomb Nachos
Tortilla Chips topped with chopped tails in mild sauce, chopped mozzarella sticks, fries & blue cheese.
$15.99
Buffalo Chicken Nacho
Tortilla chips topped with chopped mild buffalo tails, melted mozzarella cheese & ranch drizzle.
$13.99
Oaxaca Nachos
Mexican seasoned shredded beef, cheddar cheese sauce, guacamole, sour cream & jalapeños. *May substitute chicken*
$15.99
Cheese Steak Nachos
Tortilla chips topped with shredded rib-eye steak, cheese sauce, fried onions & hot cherry pepper relish
$15.99
Egg Rolls
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
Served with side of sriracha ketchup.
$12.99
Buffalo Mac & Cheese Eggrolls
Mac & cheese mixed with chopped tails and mild sauce. Served with cheese sauce mixed with mild.
$12.99
Chicken Parmigiana Egg Rolls
Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella cheese, & red sauce fried golden brown. Served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.
$12.99
Italian Beef Egg Rolls
Italian marinated beef, & provolone cheese. Served with a side of Au Jus.
$12.99
Smash Burgers
Classic Smash Burger
2 4oz season smashed patties, topped homemade burger sauce & your choice of cheese.
$12.99
French Onion Smash Burger
2 4oz seasoned smashed patties, topped with caramelized onions, provolone & Swiss cheese.
$14.99
Pizza Smash Burger
2 4oz season smashed patties, topped with homemade marinara sauce, pepperoni chips & melted mozzarella cheese.
$14.99
Italian Long Hot Smash Burger
1 4oz seasoned smash patty, topped with ham, capicola, provolone cheese & sautéed long hots.
$14.99
BBQ Bacon Smash Burger
2 4oz seasoned smashed patties, topped with homemade BBQ sauce, bacon, onion rings, & sliced cheddar cheese.
$14.99
Specialty Cold Sub
Homemade Tuna Salad on Ciabatta
Whipped tuna, celery, onions, salt, pepper & mayo mixed together. Served on a Ciabatta Roll.
$10.49
Dill Pickle Chicken Salad on a Ciabatta Roll
Chicken, dills pickles, celery, onion, salt, pepper & mayo all mixed together. Served on a Ciabatta Roll.
$11.99
Arugula & Burrata on a Ciabatta Roll
Arugula, burrata cheese, blistered tomatoes, & balsamic glaze. Served on a ciabatta roll. *Try with chicken cutlet or breaded eggplant. $4.99*
$12.99
Italian Burrata on a Seeded Roll
Italian meats, burrata, & roasted red peppers topped with Oil, Vinegar, Salt, Pepper & Oregano. Served on a Seeded Roll
$14.99
Honey Turkey BLT Wrap
Sliced turkey topped with lettuce, tomato, bacon & homemade honey mustard dressing. Served on a Flour Wrap.
$13.99
BLT Wrap
Bacon, lettuce, tomato with Rosemary Mayo on your choice of a flour or wheat tortilla
$10.49
Veggie Hummus Wrap
Hummus, avocado, roasted red peppers, spinach, red onions & feta cheese. Served on a flour wrap.
$13.99
Costello's Pizzeria & Wings
Smithville, NJ knows pizza - welcome to Costello's Pizzeria & Wings! We're an independent restaurant that our customers can rely on. That's because we provide excellent service and food every time they dine with us. Consistency is key, so if you're a pizza lover in Atlantic County, you can always count on us. When it comes to pizza, we have plenty to offer on our menu. For a start, you can try some of our regular options such as our cheese pie. Or you can even create yours and select the toppings you prefer. Additionally, we serve a number of Gourmet pizzas. These include our BBQ Chicken, Margherita, Meat Lovers, and Da Veggie pie, to name a few. And if you need to grab some on the go, then our pizza by the slice is the right choice for you. Furthermore, we offer different appetizers, salads, calzones, various subs & wraps, pasta, desserts, and others. Plus, we cannot forget about our youngest customers, so we provide an excellent kid's menu as well. Oh, and, if you have an upcoming event or special occasion, you should definitely check out our catering services, too. Stop by for lunch or dinner at any time. You're in for a memorable meal and some outstanding service. But if you'd prefer to enjoy our dishes at home, then you can order us for takeout or delivery on Slice!
Full Hours